Monday, January 18, 2010

Bag of Balls

A bag contains 9 colored balls: 3 red, 3 yellow, and 3 green. Three balls are removed from the bag, one at a time.

1. The first and third ball removed were not a pair of yellow and green.

2. A green ball was removed before a red one, if and only if, a yellow was taken after a red.

3. A green was not removed later than a red one.

4. The first color removed was different from both the second and third.

What color were the 3 balls removed from the bag ... and in what order were they taken?

2 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Bag of Balls

1. The first and third ball removed were not a pair of yellow and green.

2. A green ball was removed before a red one, if and only if, a yellow was taken after a red.

3. A green was not removed later than a red one.

4. The first color removed was different from both the second and third.
Abbrieviate red,yellow green as R,Y,G

Assume 1st ball R.
2nd ball:
-R violates rule 4
-Y violates rule 2
-G violates rule 3
1st ball R invalid

Assume 1st ball Y.
2nd ball:
-R ok
-Y violates rule 4
-G ok

For YR:
3rd ball
-R ok
-Y violates rule 4
-G violates rule 3
YRR is a valid solution.

For YG:
-R violates rule 2
-Y violates rule 4
-G violates rule 1
YG invalid

Assume 1st ball G.
2nd ball:
-R ok
-Y ok
-G violates rule 4

For GR:
3rd ball
-R violates rule 2
-Y violates rule 1
-G violates rule 4
GR invalid

For GY:
3rd ball
-R violates rule 2
-Y violates rule 1
-G violates rule 4
GY invalid

Thus only YRR is valid.

Answer:
1st ball Yellow
2nd ball Red
3rd ball Red

Cam

January 19, 2010 12:04 AM  
Anonymous Zaux said...

Hi Cam ... correct you are.

January 19, 2010 4:02 AM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home